Freedom According to Islam and Capitalism

Freedom According to Islam and Capitalism When we start comparing freedom according to Islam with freedom according to the democratic capitalist system, basic differences appear to us between the freedom which has been lived by the capitalist society and advocated by capitalism, and the freedom whose banner Islam has borne and adopted by the society which Islam has created, providing its own experience on history’s stage. When we say “freedom”, we mean thereby its general meaning; that is, rejection of others’ domination, for this concept is the one we can find in both civilizations, even when its frame and intellectual base vary in both.

Freedom According to Islam and CapitalismWe have come to know, from the above contents that freedom is the central
point in the capitalist thinking, and the concept of "insurance" (assurance) is
the basic revolving point in the socialist and communist sytstems.

For this purpose we will be studying, comparatively, the position of Islam and
capitalism from freedom, comparing thereafter between the "insurance" according
to Islam and according to the Marxist creed.

When we say "freedom", we mean thereby its general meaning; that is, rejection
of others’ domination, for this concept is the one we can find in both
civilizations, even when its frame and intellectual base vary in both.

When we start comparing freedom according to Islam with freedom according to the
democratic capitalist system, basic differences appear to us between the freedom
which has been lived by the capitalist society and advocated by capitalism, and
the freedom whose banner Islam has borne and adopted by the society which Islam
has created, providing its own experience on history’s stage. Each of these
norms of freedom bears the stamp of civilization to which it belongs and with
whose concepts of the cosmos and life it agrees, expressing the intellectual and
psychological state that civilization created in history.

Freedom, in the capitalist civilization, has started as a bitterly overwhelming
doubt, and this doubt changed, in its revolutionary expansion, to a doctrinal
belief in freedom. Contrary to this is freedom in the Islamic civilization, for
here it is but an expression of a firm central conviction (i.e., belief in God)
from which freedom derives its revolution. According to the firmness of this
conviction and the depth of its implication in man’s life do the revolutionary
powers in that freedom multiply.

Capitalist freedom has a positive connotation. It considers man to possess his
own self, faring with it as he pleases, without submitting in that to any
external authority. For this purpose, all social institutions, which affect
man’s life, derive their legal right to control every individual from the
individuals themselves! Freedom, according to Islam, maintains the revolutionary
aspect of freedom, to liberate man from the control of idols; all idols from
whose yoke humanity has been suffering across history. But it erects this great
task of liberation upon the basis of a submission purely for Allah, and for
Allah alone.

Therefore, man’s submission to God in Islam (instead of possessing his own self,
according to capitalism) is the tool whereby man breaks all other norms of
submission or slavery, for this sort of submission, in its sublime meaning,
makes him feel that he, together with all other sorts of power with which he
coexists, stands on the same grounds before one Lord. Therefore, no power on
earth has the right to fare with his destiny as it pleases or controls his
existence and life …

Freedom, according to the precepts of the capitalist civilization, is a natural
right for man, and he may give his right up whenever he wills. But it is not so
according to Islam! Freedom according to Islam is essentially tied to submission
to Allah!

Islam does not permit man to yield, be enslaved or give his freedom up:

Do not be a slave of others, since Allah created you free. [Nahjul Balaghah –
Ali ibn Abi Talib]

Man, according to Islam, is to be accounted for the use of his freedom, and
freedom is not a state of irresponsibility.

This is the difference between both norms of freedom in their general features.


Selected Chapter from Contemporary Man and the Social Problem by Shaheed
Muhammad Baqir Al-Sadr

Check Also

Without piety, one’s heart cannot realize the truth

From the words of Ayatollah Khamenei: As long as one is not pious, he or …