Shiite

Search

Advertisements

 

Who's Online

We have 37 guests online
Corruption within Islamic Organizations PDF Print E-mail
Written by Noor Ali   
Saturday, 05 January 2008
At one time I used to enjoy dropping a dollar or more in those little boxes placed at many local grocery stores. After all, the colorful label on them had a verse from the Holy Quran on it, explaining the benefits of helping orphans. Yes orphans, that's where the money donated was supposed to go. I don't like looking at those boxes anymore, it always brings about feelings of guilt inside of me. The woman in the blue scarf in front of me in line just put in a $5, little does she know that the money will never be reached by those in need.

I used to drop the same donations boxes off at the stores during my stint with one of large Islamic Organizations. I used to also count the donations and send them in to the heads of the organization. That was my duty, I had no idea what happened to the donations later on. The money was supposed to help Orphans in Iraq, Lebanon, and a few other countries. Seeing as the organization was well known; we received a large amount of donations. People trusted us to deliver the money to its rightful owners.

One day, after "proving my loyalty"; I was allowed to attend one of the meetings that the head committee had weekly. On the table, were the envelopes of donations that I had brought in with me, to my utter surprise and disgust about 5 people decided to just take the money from their envelopes and pocket them. Apparently I showed my emotion too well, immediately the head of the organization said to me " Sister, running an organization isn't simple, as the heads we need some form of compensation. Whatever is left over from what we take, will be sent to the orphans." I of course wasn't going to accept this; no decent human being would. The topic quickly changed to the Muharram program we were planning, the same people who just stole money from orphans, were now talking about the greatness of Imam Al Hussain. It would have been more fitting for them to pretend to emulate Yazeed. The meeting itself was quite possibly an hour or two long, it felt like forever. I pulled to the side one of the more well known and influential members of the organization, and voiced my opposition to the blatant stealing of the money. Later that night, I was asked to step down from the organization. It doesn't take much to figure out why I was asked to leave.

I never told anyone what I saw, no one would believe me. I'd come across as a bitter liar trying to bring down the Holy Saints who ran the organization. There is no accountability among Islamic Organizations. No one to go and tell this to, the only thing stopping people from stealing; is the fear of Allah. Apparently that isn't enough for many. I'm sure cases such as this aren't isolated; Muslims are blind sheep for the most part. We have set the standard pretty low for our organizations, there will be no revolution against the orgs that steal. There won't be an awakening among us. There will be nothing. Maybe that is why I've kept quiet, this article will maybe inspire some people to push for change. I wonder what I will say to my Lord when I stand before Him, will I be excused for standing by and letting the corruption continue? I dread the thought of one of the orphans coming to me and wondering why I allowed their money to be taken. Would they understand that I couldn't do much? Would they view me as a willing accomplice?

I by no means wish to discourage my brothers and sisters from donating. I simply hope we can tackle the issues of corruption within our communities. We as the followers of Imam Al Asr, must take a stand, we must strongly fight corruption. As those who claim loyalty to the Holy Household, it is unacceptable for us to sit back and watch the oppression done by some of the elites in our communities. The honest organizations must be given more support, while at the same time, the masses must disassociate themselves from the unethical and dishonest ones.

May Allah grant us all success, and may we be granted the honor of being among the true followers of our Awaited Imam.


Comments (22)
1. Written by Abbas on 05-01-2008 17:41
 
 
Salaam 
 
I can blv what sis is saying...I can ralate to it. 
 
But who is to challenge the pious goons?
 
2. Written by Ali Askari on 06-01-2008 02:37
 
 
Assalamu aleikum 
 
I feel like i want to hit those "pious ones" really hard.
 
3. Written by mustajeer on 06-01-2008 07:39
 
 
it is difficult to believe but that is the bitter truth and such things do happen.In fact,you would see such types of people who for their own selfish interests and desires would put a dress of religion in front of their evil selfish motives. 
Let us not be deceived  
by people praying on  
the first row for  
example, to be  
genuinely of the pious  
category. 
The likes of such are similar to Munafiqeen.They deserve double punishment.More severe than even the kafirs! 
these are people who are enemies of Islam by living within Islam... 
May Allah protect us from all this but Sis you need to expose such elements and fear no one BUT Allah.
 
4. Written by Saeed on 06-01-2008 17:52
 
 
It always been like this but most of us ignores for reasons of our own.Are muslims a different species,they are the same humans as everyone else.Why fret.
 
5. Written by Fatima on 06-01-2008 19:10
 
 
We can't ignore something that clearly goes against our religion and basic morals.
 
6. Written by Abbas on 06-01-2008 21:46
 
 
To be honest, the problem is some of the impported "mullas" are more concerned about protectng their jobs and since the organising committees are ppl other than these maulana so they find rule bending easy. but in any case it is our resposnibility as well to uncover such elements, of course within the islamic moral code, but nevertheless uncover them. and moreover i think we need to encourage our younger generation to learn religion so that this gap can easily be filled (no more imported mullas).
 
7. Written by Muhammad on 07-01-2008 13:14
 
 
'D3D'E 9DJCE 
By Allah these are people who look like Ali ibn Abi Talib in appearance but in actuality they are the complete opp. Our Imams were for JUSTICE "ADL" as Imam Ali has said that "he wouldn't have even usurped a grain from an ant"; let along a human being. Such people are far far away from the teachings of our Ahlul bayt. Ya Amatullah you have done justice in exposing what din-ul-huqq commands muslims amr-bil maroof nahya anil munkar which is an oath for ALL MUSLIMS. Pray for those who have bacome lethargic and unconscious of Allah swt may Allah give us the ability to bring about justice and equality for all insha'Allah. 'D3D'E 9DJCE
 
8. Written by Karbala on 07-01-2008 13:24
 
 
Salaam Alykum, 
 
The problem is nothing to do with the imported or home-grown mullahs. Abbas, what you have stated can be said about the home-grown so called mullahs too. Take a walk down in London and notice the bling bling of certain so called scholars. 
 
What is needed is more transparency from the organisation which deal with khums and zakaat money. The accounts should be scrutinized by a board of trustees and the public hence everyone is aware of where the money is coming from and where it is going to. You will always find corruption in places but what can be done is take measures to ensure that such corruption does not spread and causes the whole organisation or charity to collapse and the whole purpose of the organisation goes out the window. 
 
WSalaams
 
9. Written by seeker of truth on 08-01-2008 08:50
 
 
Fear not for Allah is the best of judges.
 
10. Written by Abbas on 08-01-2008 13:20
 
 
Salaamun Aleykum 
 
I did not mean to pin point a particular group of local leaders. But we can not deny the growing frustration among the youth that see wide gap in what these "mullas" preach and what they actually do. And the vast majority of these leaders are imported who are somehow finding it hard to adjust to realities. My point is that there should be some kind of vetting mechanism for the "imports". There must be some pre-requisites.  
Hope did not cause any hurt to anyone, though it was not my intention, I am just frustrated. 
 
WS
 
11. Written by Miqdad on 08-01-2008 15:17
 
 
It would be interesting (and NOT controversial) to give names: List the organisations that are as such, especially the one the sister is talking about, and at the same time, list the ones that are reliable.  
Yes we can blame and say how bad it is, but in order to do something we must first know the responsible in order to direct charities to the more reliable organisations. I myself, now find very easy to just totally reject giving money to ANY charity organisation, which is not good. Hence, it would be nice to know where to give ! Jazakallah
 
12. Written by SA on 09-01-2008 12:42
 
 
^ I agree with Miqdad above. It is imperative we do not support these organisations by shielding their identities so others continue to blindly give. If you fear the jusgement of men, you would not speak against these respected figures. But if you fear the judgement of Allah, you must. 
 
do it for the sake of Imam Hussein (as), who lived and died for reform of this ummah, and tackling the corruption within.
 
13. Written by Ali_askari on 10-01-2008 05:36
 
 
Matter should take to local police and if they can not do anything, then to Islamic higher auktority. Any public naming dont give justice to matter. First, investigation and then judge will tell more. Allah is the best and only real judge, but we will be also judget if rejecting to good, by not doing justice and defending it. 
 
massalam
 
14. Written by Ali_askari on 10-01-2008 05:41
 
 
If police can not do anything, then for precaution for the future; Islamic orcanisations should write clear legal contract about handeling zakat and khums, so in case of violation local aukhtorities can do something about it, whit out things getting to complicated. It would go to court in matter of fraud. 
 
Islam is perfeckt, but we must blend in to 2008 western sociaty, way that our rights can be defended but Laws of Allah will not be violated. 
 
May Allah unite ummah soon, 
YA Mahdi (AS) 
 
Massalam
 
15. Written by abul on 17-01-2008 21:22
 
 
allah works in mysterious ways, the money they take wrongfully from charity will be taken in different ways by making their minds wander off and spending money unnecessary which will constitute as 'losing money'
 
16. Written by mikail on 18-01-2008 04:37
 
 
To the sister, if this is the case of many organizations, thank you very much for letting everyone know.
 
17. Written by Dawood on 18-01-2008 06:34
 
 
These people will one day have to answer to Allah. May what they deprive the orphans and needy one day be deprived from them ya allah please cut the hands from people who take from the needy and orphans. i can not believe anyone with a Conscious will do that.
 
18. Written by shia2shia on 19-01-2008 21:53
 
 
Salaams 
 
Well, I can well believe what you have said. If only you would have mentioned the organisation also. 
 
I never give my money yo those Gangsters. Better to give in person if possible, or send it via a trusted family member or friend.
 
19. Written by H_ussein on 20-01-2008 01:06
 
 
Salaam Alaikum,  
Am really disappointed to see this coming in our society, its very discouraging for even people to donate. Its true i have heard things about frauds in charity since then i do all necessary things before selecting where i put my money otherwise i prefer to save them somwhere then lend it to someone who needs it or save it and struggle to travel somewher and take part in distributing if possible.  
Dear brothers and sisters i am happy that after this lid is opened people are feel hurt atleast the feeling is left but thats not enough and those people who are asking for names i would tel them there is no point it doesn help and those who want to complain to police if am not mistaken charity organisations are allowed to make salary payment. Leaving all this aside what needs to be done is i believe is what karbala comment 8. 'What is needed is more transparency from the organisation which deal with khums and zakaat money. The accounts should be scrutinized by a board of trustees and the public hence everyone is aware of where the money is coming from and where it is going to.'  
Oh people i call on you all bring your selves together and think of a way that a charity will work in a more transparent way, a charity which publishes its accounts every 6 months and all expenses and incomes are recorded and those people willing to recieve a copy are sent, people are free to see how things work and those who work are happy and open to show how things work with zero deffect, if money is lost then everyone should be responsible and should instead take out from their pockets generously. This will i believe encourge people who are discouraged to believe in helping through charity.  
Oh sister if you think the way i am and need help in organising or a member to help then i am willing to do all i can because ignoring this is like ignoring my religion and my existance. 
May Allah those who help themselves. 
Khudahafiz.
 
20. Written by khademat ahlulbait......... on 27-01-2008 14:45
 
 
sometimes i ask my self y?all relligion is after shias? 
is there something wrong about us?or we just speek true about ahlulbait>>laken ma agool ela naar el hatab takelhum.....sooooon as posebel salam.
 
21. Written by al_karbalay on 22-02-2008 12:08
 
 
thia is very important subject and i think thatu musy write to ayat allah syed ali sistani an dask him to find solution. i live in karbala and i asked the mangement of harram of imam hussain in karbala to make majlis in harram in arabic and farisi and enghlish lamguage because we have now in kaarbala many people from uk and usa and canda and they must know what happen in iraq and in najaf.
 
22. Written by syed adil on 23-03-2008 03:08
 
 
most of civil societies have no check and balance system.islamic org.As else where, in india also such org.are mostly headed by mullas and theyand they collect the fund from other rich country through and in the name of imam husain and mostly misuse the fund.it is reality.but we have no option.
 

Write Comment
  • Please keep the topic of messages relevant to the subject of the article.
Name:
Comment:

Code:* Code

Comments posted are the sole opinion of the author and may not necessarily reflect the opinions of AIM.

 
< Prev
Shiite